Find Homes What's My Home Worth
Neighborhood Snapshot

Anastasia Island at a Glance

⚠️ Figures shown are illustrative placeholders. Live data via RentCast loads automatically once available.

$610K
Median Home Price
88
Active Listings
Somewhat Walkable
Walkability
41
Avg Days on Market
Why Live Here

Living in Anastasia Island

Anastasia Island stretches from the historic St Augustine Lighthouse down through St Augustine Beach, offering everything from mid-century canal homes to oceanfront condos. It's close enough to downtown to feel connected, but the island pace is unmistakably slower.

Somewhat Walkable — St Augustine Beach's town center and the pier area are genuinely walkable, while the rest of the island leans car-friendly.
Education

Anastasia Island Schools

School zones change — always confirm current assignment for a specific address with the county school district.

Local Favorites

Restaurants Near Anastasia Island

South Beach Grill

A casual, longtime local favorite for burgers and seafood near St Augustine Beach.

Beachcomber Restaurant

Oceanfront dining right on A1A Beach Boulevard.

Aunt Kate's Restaurant

A waterfront seafood institution on the Tolomato River side of the island.

Get Outside

Things To Do in Anastasia Island

St. Augustine Lighthouse Anastasia State Park St. Augustine Alligator Farm St Augustine Beach Pier Surfing
Around the Neighborhood

Local Businesses & Shopping

See It For Yourself

Anastasia Island Video Tour

Drone footage of Anastasia Island, St. Augustine, FL · Watch on YouTube

IDX Feed

Anastasia Island Listings

⚠️ Illustrative examples only. Live listings via RentCast load automatically once available; MLS-sourced IDX listings are a separate future integration.

$725,000

142 Ocean Palm Dr

4 bd3 ba2,480 sqft
Schedule a Tour →

Listed by [Listing Brokerage] · [Listing Agent] · Data via RentCast

$412,000

120 Ocean Hibiscus Dr #201

2 bd2 ba1,220 sqft
Schedule a Tour →

Listed by [Listing Brokerage] · [Listing Agent] · Data via RentCast

$1,195,000

25 Coquina Ave

4 bd3 ba2,890 sqft
Schedule a Tour →

Listed by [Listing Brokerage] · [Listing Agent] · Data via RentCast

Good Questions

Anastasia Island FAQ

What is the median home price on Anastasia Island?
The median home price is approximately $610,000, ranging from beach condos in the $300s to oceanfront estates well over $1M.
Is Anastasia Island walkable?
The St Augustine Beach town center and pier area are walkable, but much of the island's residential area is more car-dependent.
What schools serve Anastasia Island?
Anastasia Island is zoned for St. Johns County Schools, generally including W. D. Hartley or Ocean Palms Elementary, Gamble Rogers Middle, and St. Augustine High or Pedro Menendez High — confirm your exact zone with the district.
What is there to do on Anastasia Island?
The St. Augustine Lighthouse, Anastasia State Park, the Alligator Farm, and St Augustine Beach's pier and surf are all on the island.

See Anastasia Island Homes in Person

Get new Anastasia Island listings the moment they hit the market, or schedule a private tour this week.

Get Listings by Email Schedule a Tour
Start your First Coast story: Find Homes Get Home Value Find My Beach Town Schedule Consultation